The 2001-02 Big South Conference Player of the Year, Andrews was a two-time first-team All-Big South honoree and an All-Southern Conference selection in her career in the maroon and gold. At the conclusion of her career, Andrews ranked among Elon's career top 10 in points (5th, 1,403), points per game (6th, 13.8 ppg in 102 contests), field goals made (8th, 496), field goals attempted (6th, 1,344), three-point field goals made (2nd, 154), three-point field goals attempted (2nd, 446), three-point field goal percentage (1st, 34.5), free throws made (6th, 257), free throw percentage (2nd, 78.4), assists (9th, 214) and blocks (6th, 48). Nearly a decade later, Andrews still holds spots on the career chart in points (7th), points per game (7th), field goals made (10th), field goals attempted (7th), three-pointers made (3rd), three-point attempts (4th), three-point percentage (3rd), free throws made (8th) and free throw percentage (3rd). Andrews was a part of Elon's first SoCon team and netted a career-high 35 points in the program's first league win, a 79-75 decision at Appalachian State. The 35 point-performance is tied for the fourth-most points ever by an Elon player in a game. Her personal-best 13 free throws made in a win over William & Mary are tied for the third-highest free throw total by an Elon player and she twice matched a school record by going 11-for-11 from the charity stripe in a contest. Andrews, who was a two-time recipient of Elon's Stein H. Basnight Award presented to the top female athlete at the university, was a Big South All-Rookie Team selection in 2000-01. Her senior campaign was cut short due to an ACL injury. At that time, she was leading the SoCon with 18.9 points per game. The Hudson, N.C., native was ranked as high as 23rd in the nation in scoring that season and collected two SoCon Player of the Month honors.
